Nomination Announcement

On Wednesday, former President Donald Trump announced the nomination of Casey Means to the position of Surgeon General, following his withdrawal of Dr. Janette Nesheiwat’s nomination. While Nesheiwat, a former Fox News contributor, faced scrutiny over her qualifications, Means’ appointment is generating significant debate.

Trump’s Endorsement

Trump has publicly supported Means, stating, “Casey has impeccable ‘MAHA’ credentials,” and emphasized that she would collaborate closely with Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. to address the nation’s health challenges. The goal, as outlined by Trump, is to tackle the “Chronic Disease Epidemic” and promote better health for all Americans.

Criticism and Qualifications

Despite Trump’s support, concerns have been voiced regarding Means’ qualifications for the role. In an unexpected admission, Trump mentioned, “I don’t know her; I listened to the recommendation of Bobby,” referring to Kennedy.

Medical professionals have expressed skepticism about Means’ ability to adequately fulfill the Surgeon General’s responsibilities, especially considering her lack of an active medical license since 2019 and her incomplete surgical training.

Background on Means

Means, who refers to herself as a “former surgeon,” left her residency at Oregon Health and Science University partway through. Additionally, she advocates for “functional medicine,” a practice criticized for lacking rigorous scientific support. During the COVID-19 pandemic, she controversially suggested that enhancing one’s metabolic health could prevent most COVID-19 fatalities.

Responses to Criticism

In the face of mounting criticism, a spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services directed inquiries to a post by Kennedy, who alleged that criticisms of Means were fueled by opposition from pharmaceutical interests. He remarked on social media that these entities strive to defame both him and Trump, suggesting a broader conspiracy against their agendas.

When pressed for specifics regarding the criticisms, HHS did not provide a response.

Controversial Views

Beyond her professional qualifications, Means has articulated opinions that are considered fringe by many within the medical community. She has publicly opposed hormonal birth control, labeling it as a “disrespect of life” in discussions with conservative commentators, and has shared views that align with anti-vaccine sentiments.

Defining the Role

The Surgeon General is often referred to as “the nation’s doctor” and is charged with disseminating the best scientific guidance to improve public health and reduce illness risk. Given Means’ unconventional stance and background, her nomination raises critical questions about her suitability for this influential role.