As the MLB season unfolds, baseball enthusiasts are once again faced with the challenge of deciding which teams to watch. The 2025 MLB Watchability Index has been updated to rank teams based on their entertainment value, offering an engaging look at the season’s most compelling squads.

Using a revised formula, teams are evaluated across several key categories, accumulating a maximum score of 40 points. Each team’s excitement factor is assessed based on the following criteria:

• Star Power (10 points): Based on the players included in the MLB Rank Top 100.
• Young Talent (10 points): Focused on players in their first or second MLB seasons along with potential call-ups.
• Baserunning (5 points): Evaluates the overall speed of the team, including stolen bases.
• Defense (5 points): Considers both team defense and standout fielders capable of making highlight plays.
• Minutiae (5 points): Encompasses fun elements like ballpark aesthetics, team uniforms, and quirky characters.
• Bonus Points (5 points): Awarded for any other factors deemed worthy of recognition.

American League Insights

Chicago White Sox

Total Score: 14

The White Sox, after a challenging 2023 season with a record of 121 losses, have shown some improvement early in the new season. However, their watchability remains limited due to an absence of standout players beyond a few promising rookies.

Colorado Rockies

Total Score: 12

Colorado continues to face challenges in maintaining relevance in the MLB landscape. The team’s defensive prowess does offer some excitement, with rookies adding a glimmer of hope.

Miami Marlins

Total Score: 11

Noteworthy for unexpected managerial decisions, the Marlins have gained attention despite their struggles. Their young roster and curious tactical approaches make them a focal point for viewers.

Minnesota Twins

Total Score: 11

While there isn’t a singular superstar to draw viewers, a mix of youth and some exciting performances might improve their watchability as potential rising stars emerge.

Pittsburgh Pirates

Total Score: 14

The Pirates have shown sparks of interest, particularly with the emergence of young pitcher Paul Skenes. Yet, they still grapple with consistency and off-field challenges.

Los Angeles Angels

Total Score: 14.5

With Mike Trout as the centerpiece, the Angels have potential for a strong season, but questions linger about the development of their younger players.

Texas Rangers

Total Score: 19.5

After a World Series championship last season, the Rangers remain a compelling team, bolstered by strong newcomers, although maintaining consistency will be key.

Cleveland Guardians

Total Score: 16.5

Having made a deep playoff run last year, the Guardians are an interesting watch, with standout players and potential star prospects contributing to their overall appeal.

Seattle Mariners

Total Score: 17

With Mike Trout as a top attraction, the Mariners aim to captivate audiences, particularly if their roster’s potential translates into exciting play.

National League Highlights

Atlanta Braves

Total Score: 19

Despite a slow start, the Braves boast star players and several intriguing prospects, ensuring a high level of entertainment for their fans.

Chicago Cubs

Total Score: 19.5

The Cubs have gathered an exciting mix of young players, enhancing their watchability this season. Day games at Wrigley Field only add to the charm.

Philadelphia Phillies

Total Score: 21

With a star-studded lineup and the best rotation in baseball, the Phillies have a compelling mix of talent that promises to entertain their fan base.

New York Mets

Total Score: 21.5

The Mets present a powerful roster loaded with top talent, showcasing thrilling play throughout the season. Their star-studded lineup draws viewers week after week.

San Diego Padres

Total Score: 20.5

With an intriguing mix of talent and a vibrant ballpark atmosphere, the Padres maintain significant viewer interest, particularly within their existing rivalries.